~ The Book of Unknown Americans, by Cristina Henríquez ~
The title and the first few pages immediately tell you what the author is trying to accomplish here: tell the stories of Americans whose accomplishments rarely get attention, who both stand out and are invisible in mainstream America, whose hopeful journeys to a new country are similar to so many others, but who are often (especially these days) reviled and threatened and described in almost inhuman terms.
Two families form the center of the novel, while other immigrants surround them. The Riveras — Arturo and Alma — have a daughter, Maribel, 15, whose brain injury in Mexico left her passive, with poor short-term memory. They were told that American special-ed schools were the most likely to help, so Arturo took a job picking mushrooms in Delaware. A long truck drive later, they end up in a cheap apartment:
Two stories, made of cinder blocks and cement, an outdoor walkway that ran the length of the second floor with metal staircases at either end, pieces of broken Styrofoam in the grass, a chain-link fence along the perimeter of the lot, cracks in the asphalt.
An unlovely place where the nearest source of food is the gas station.
Everyone in the apartment complex is brown-skinned, a first-generation immigrant, and Spanish-speaking. One of these families is the Toros, who left Panama after the devastation of the American invasion. Enrique, their older son, is a basketball star with a full college scholarship. Mayor, the younger, is less lucky:
School had started two weeks earlier, and even though I had told myself that this would be the year the other kids stopped picking on me, the year that I actually fit in for once in my life, things already weren’t going as planned.
Mayor is the same age as Maribel, and immediately taken with her beauty as are most boys. A slow relationship develops between the two; unusual, because of Maribel’s limited conversation and because her parents never let her out alone. Yet Mayor finds pleasure in her quiet company, and she slowly becomes more responsive and interactive.
The only other teenager with a major role is Garrett Miller, and he is a caricature of the worst of white entitled American youth: sneering at the immigrants, bullying their kids, hassling Mayor, leering at Maribel and assaulting her. But then, given the way immigrants are described by some politicians these days, this turning of the tables hardly seems unfair.
The novel is told largely in the voices of Alma and Mayor, with alternating chapters in each voice. The author chose to intersperse additional chapters in the voices of other residents of the apartment complex: Benny Quinto, Gustavo Milhojas, Quisqueya Solis, Micho Alvarez, and so on. This, for me, was a mistake, as it stole the momentum from the main story. Some of the backstories were interesting, but I found myself skipping over these chapters especially towards the latter half of the novel.
Henríquez does a nice job of capturing the reactions of the immigrants to the new country. For them, America is far from a ‘promised land full of opportunity’, but is limited by the color of their skins and their English. They miss certain things about their home countries, while always conscious that those countries themselves have changed since they left.
We’re Americans now. I’m a line cook at a diner, and I make enough to provide for my family. Celia and I feel gratified when we see Enrique and Mayor doing well here. Maybe they wouldn’t have done so well in Panama. Maybe they wouldn’t have had the same opportunities. So that makes coming here worth it. We’re citizens, and if someone asks me where my home is, I say los Estados Unidos. I say it proudly.
[Rafael Toro, Mayor’s father]
There is a pleasing scene when the heating goes out and the residents gather in the Toros’ apartment for warmth. While they are all Spanish-speaking, they take joy in representing their various countries: Mexico, Panama, Nicaragua, Puerto Rico, Venezuela, Paraguay… it underscores both the similarities and the differences within the group.
This novel is heartfelt, but a limitation is that it shows only one face of American immigration: the model immigrant. The characters are all hardworking, devoted to their families, scrimping and saving to get by on miserable paychecks from backbreaking work. The author wrote the book in homage to her father, a Panamanian immigrant, and to give a voice to those like him whose stories are rarely told, and in that she has succeeded admirably.
Being American, or more accurately, becoming American … somewhere between the extremes of the cynicism, the xenophobia and the idealism – it’s a unique experience.
I was in Europe this summer and on multiple occasions ran into Americans – and everywhere there was the flash of recognition and camaraderie despite the differences.
I finally got round to reading this book, and was both pleasantly surprised as well as a little disappointed with it. It is not as paradoxical as I made that sound! I was quite taken by the interspersing stories of immigrants from a range of Central and South American countries, each with their different backgrounds, stories, journeys, but with common struggles. It is nice to imagine all the different Spanish accents these chapters would have been spoken in. However, the weakness of this novel is that the stories are just presented, they don’t tie into the main story line, and they don’t even all weave to each other. Apart from having different voices, the structure of the novel could have been more coherent in incorporating those voices. Also, each is supposed to be very distinct – and yet the style of writing came across as virtually the same person! It needed to vary more in tone and style, if it is to convince that these are all extremely different immigrants from very different places in the world.
The relationship between Arturo and Alma was nicely sketched, as was that of Celia and Rafa. Indissoluble loyalty does not mean smooth relationships! But fraught relationships likewise do not then necessitate a loss of solidarity. Nice nuances.
The strict parental control and upbringing of children in the Latino cultures was highlighted, no doubt to juxtapose with mainstream communities. That said, Mayor, whom I am sure all readers found endearing, did not behave as a model minority – he breaks rules – albeit for the best of reasons. It is probably fair enough that this segment of the immigrant community – those found in this particular apartment block – are presented as fairly law abiding, hard working immigrants – they are homogeneous in some ways after all, having middle class aspirations and reasonable education. Birds of a feather, and all that. This is a mere sliver of the immigrant community represented, one imagines, not the whole.
I found the ending ironic at best, and weak at worst. SPOILER warning!
Why would Arturo, who was so unfairly treated and who lost his life, be so keen on the US in his afterlife? What reason has he for loving it? It seemed just a bit pat, the ending, like it was written to wrap things up prettily, rather than feasibly.